SpinnachBuying guides that show their work.

Debt relief: the fee, risk and tax rules to know before you enroll

Debt settlement, counseling plans and negotiating yourself work very differently. Here is what federal regulators say about fees, lawsuits, credit and taxes.

Bring this to the call

CompareOption AOption BOption C
Type of program: settlement, counseling plan, or direct negotiation
When fees are charged and how they are calculated
Whether you are told to stop paying creditors
What happens if a creditor sues
Possible tax on forgiven amounts

Blank on purpose. Fill it in from each company’s written terms — we don’t score options for you.

Fees come after results

The FTC says a debt settlement company can't collect its fees from you before it settles your debt (FTC). The CFPB adds that debt settlement companies often charge expensive fees and to be wary of any company that charges before settling (CFPB). Write the exact fee formula on your worksheet, in the company's words.

The risks while you wait

Settlement companies often ask you to stop paying creditors, which can bring late fees, penalty interest and more aggressive collection (CFPB). The CFPB warns that working with a debt settlement company may lead to a creditor filing a debt collection lawsuit against you, that settlement can hurt your credit, and that it may leave you deeper in debt than when you started (CFPB).

Alternatives

The CFPB lists other routes: a credit counselor can help build a repayment plan with your creditors, you can negotiate directly with a creditor or collector, and a bankruptcy attorney can explain your legal options (CFPB). Ask any program you talk to which of these it is, and which it is not.

Taxes

The FTC warns that savings from debt relief services could be considered income and taxable (FTC). The IRS explains how canceled debt is treated and the exceptions that may apply (IRS). The CFPB suggests talking with a tax advisor or attorney before you settle (CFPB).

Some bankruptcy attorneys offer an initial consultation for free, according to the CFPB (CFPB). Whichever route you take, get every fee and every promise in writing before you enroll, and keep copies of each statement your creditors send while you decide.

Before you sign, ask

  • Do you charge any fee before a debt is settled?
  • Will you ask me to stop paying my creditors?
  • What happens if a creditor sues me while I am in the program?
  • Could any forgiven amount be taxable?
  • What are the alternatives you are not offering?

Sources

  1. FTC — How To Get Out of Debtconsumer.ftc.gov
  2. CFPB — What is a debt relief program?consumerfinance.gov
  3. IRS Topic 431 — Canceled debtirs.gov

Optional · paid offer

Debt relief consultation

A consultation about debt relief options for unsecured debt.

Get this guide’s offer

Spinnach may be paid if you respond to this offer. It is shown because it matches this guide’s topic, not because of anything in the guide above. Disclosure.

Spinnach editors research and write Spinnach guides from public sources. This guide is general information, not legal, tax, medical or financial advice. Confirm every term in writing with the company before you sign. Found an error? editors@spinnach.com.